Ignite Realtime: s2s dont work for me. ...

This thread is archived

24 Replies Last post: Jun 30, 2005 9:52 AM by Jonathan Yih

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 17, 2005 12:21 PM

s2s dont work for me.

I use Jive Messenger (nightly build from 13/06/05) and can not connect to another server (jabberd 1.4). Jive Messenger can send, but can not receive messages.

Is anyone able to help me with this?

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 17, 2005 10:42 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hey Jonathan,

First off, download the latest nightly build that contains many s2s improvements and better logging.

Things to check/do:
. The hostname used by your JM server must be registered in the DNS so that remote servers may be able to connect to your JM server
. Servers will communicate using port 5269 so make sure that that port is opened in the firewall. A simple test that you can try is doing a telnet to the JM''s hostname at port 5269 from the remote server.
. Open the Admin Console. Click on Logs > Debug and enable the Debug Log. Copy the information in the debug.log so I can analyze where the problem is.

If your jabberd1.4 server is publicly accesible I may try connecting from my local(development) server and check the issue. So give me the hostname of the jabberd server if the server is publicly accesible.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 18, 2005 3:26 AM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

The jabber 1.4 i used is the amessage.de server of Matthias Wimmer with public access.

But certainly you are right, i found a problem with the DNS.

Message was edited by:
Jonathan Yih

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 20, 2005 4:35 AM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hi
DNS working now and the port is free, but my problem is still there.
There must be something i do wrong, so here the requested log. I hope you can find my mistake.

regards

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 20, 2005 10:42 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hey Jonathan,

Looking at your log I don''t see any s2s communication. After the server has been started could you try sending a message to and from amessage.de? FYI, I tried connecting from my local server to amessage.de and it worked fine both ways.

You should see something like this in your log when sending a message TO amessage.de:

2005.06.20 12:28:04 OS - Trying to connect to amessage.de:5269
2005.06.20 12:28:05 OS - Connection to amessage.de:5269 successfull
2005.06.20 12:28:06 OS - Sent dialback key to host: amessage.de id: 050b95ca5f08b9df860006feaea87f9f8898c566 from domain: gato.dyndns.org
2005.06.20 12:28:07 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/212.112.238.55,port=46627,localport=5269
2005.06.20 12:28:07 AS - Verifying key for host: amessage.de id: 050b95ca5f08b9df860006feaea87f9f8898c566
2005.06.20 12:28:07 AS - Key was: VALID for host: amessage.de id: 050b95ca5f08b9df860006feaea87f9f8898c566
2005.06.20 12:28:07 AS - Connection closed for host: amessage.de id: 050b95ca5f08b9df860006feaea87f9f8898c566
2005.06.20 12:28:08 OS - Validation GRANTED from: amessage.de id: 050b95ca5f08b9df860006feaea87f9f8898c566 for domain: gato.dyndns.org

and something like this when receiving FROM amessage.de:

2005.06.20 12:29:43 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/212.112.238.55,port=46690,localport=5269
2005.06.20 12:29:43 RS - Received dialback key from host: amessage.de to: gato.dyndns.org
2005.06.20 12:29:43 RS - Trying to connect to Authoritative Server: amessage.de:5264
2005.06.20 12:29:43 RS - Connection to AS: amessage.de:5264 successfull
2005.06.20 12:29:43 RS - Asking AS to verify dialback key for idd9551065
2005.06.20 12:29:44 RS - Key was VERIFIED by the Authoritative Server for: amessage.de
2005.06.20 12:29:44 RS - Closing connection to Authoritative Server: amessage.de
2005.06.20 12:29:44 RS - Sending key verification result to OS: amessage.de

Let me know how it goes.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 20, 2005 12:49 PM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hello

1. Thx for your help!!!
2. Sorry, i missed something.

So here the log again after i tried some messages and actions from my jive messenger to the amessage.de server and backwards.
I pasted everything i found in ''debug'' with activated logging.
Maybe i am too stupid for all this ...

best regards

2005.06.20 11:19:42 Stopping server
2005.06.20 11:19:42 Logging off zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi on org.jivesoftware.messenger.net.SocketConnection@198e8b4 socket: Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.111.171,port=1954,localport=5222 session: org.jivesoftware.messenger.ClientSession@1d5b89c status: -1 address: zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi id: c9a61d6e presence:
<presence from="zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi">
<priority>5</priority>
</presence>
2005.06.20 11:19:53 Loading plugin admin
2005.06.20 11:29:39 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.111.171,port=1989,localport=5222
2005.06.20 11:38:22 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.111.171,port=1995,localport=5222
2005.06.20 11:39:39 Logging off dfg@kub.kicks-ass.net/Exodus on org.jivesoftware.messenger.net.SocketConnection@4b0bbb socket: Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.111.171,port=1995,localport=5222 session: org.jivesoftware.messenger.ClientSession@ef4504 status: 3 address: dfg@kub.kicks-ass.net/Exodus id: f6196c90 presence:
<presence type="unavailable" from="dfg@kub.kicks-ass.net/Exodus"/>
2005.06.20 11:39:41 Logging off zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi on org.jivesoftware.messenger.net.SocketConnection@9c176c socket: Sockethttp://addr=p508A6FAB.dip.t-dialin.net/80.138.111.171,port=1989,localport=5222 session: org.jivesoftware.messenger.ClientSession@1c5ddd3 status: 3 address: zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi id: a9d7d53c presence:
<presence from="zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi">
<priority>5</priority>
</presence>
2005.06.20 11:39:48 Stopping server
2005.06.20 19:20:21 Loading plugin admin
2005.06.20 19:23:35 Stopping server
2005.06.20 19:23:43 Loading plugin admin
2005.06.20 19:23:58 Stopping server
2005.06.20 19:24:50 Loading plugin admin
2005.06.20 19:25:13 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.66.102,port=2054,localport=5222
2005.06.20 19:25:48 Logging off zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Exodus on org.jivesoftware.messenger.net.SocketConnection@106df95 socket: Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.66.102,port=2054,localport=5222 session: org.jivesoftware.messenger.ClientSession@40afb9 status: 3 address: zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Exodus id: e224b09 presence:
<presence type="unavailable" from="zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Exodus"/>
2005.06.20 19:26:03 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.66.102,port=2061,localport=5222
2005.06.20 19:33:58 Logging off zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi on org.jivesoftware.messenger.net.SocketConnection@6de609 socket: Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.66.102,port=2061,localport=5222 session: org.jivesoftware.messenger.ClientSession@1195c2b status: 3 address: zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi id: fba66078 presence:
<presence type="unavailable" from="zombie@kub.kicks-ass.net/Psi">
<status>Logged out</status>
</presence>
2005.06.20 19:34:05 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.66.102,port=2078,localport=5222

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 20, 2005 1:53 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Jonathan,

This is weird. I don''t see any server-to-server trace in your debug log.

1) Could you check that you are in fact using the latest nightly build? You can check the info logged in the info file which shows the version you are using or you can go to the Admin Console and check if you have Sessions > Server Sessions.

2) How are you testing the server-to-server communication? Using a client connected to your JM local server try sending a message to "aaaa@amessage.de". That should generate some new entries in your debug.log.

Let me know how it goes.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 21, 2005 9:59 AM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

ok, it is shown it is 2.1.5. Right/ontop admin screen.

I messaged aaaa@amessage.de and absolutely nothing changed in any of those logfiles. I only get changes when i send messages internal of my local server,
(client to client inside same server).
In case of any mistakes i reinstall now and will test again.

best regards

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 21, 2005 10:02 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hey Jonathan,

Now your log makes more sense.

Server-to-server is not supported in JM 2.1.5. You will need to install the latest nightly build to take advantage of s2s. After you have installed the latest nightly build you should see that the version 2.2.0 Beta 1 is being used.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 21, 2005 11:31 AM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

S2S is working now.

THANK YOU VERY VERY MUCH!!!

best regards
J. Yih

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 21, 2005 11:35 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

You are very welcome. Enjoy s2s

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 24, 2005 12:45 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

My msg was repeated below and this one was deleted to keep forum sorted

Message was edited by:
Jonathan Yih

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 24, 2005 12:37 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Could you be a little more specific?

BTW, try updating to the latest nightly build.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 24, 2005 1:08 PM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Sorry i was too slow in typing/editing

Problems continue in different form.

Actualy the jive messenger is invisible to some other servers and messages work only one-way. Means jive messenger can send to other servers, but can not receive messages from other servers.

This is the message the guy from amessage got from his server:
Failed to deliver stanza to other server while sent out dialback request: 83.243.42.79: Connected (tried to send data before stream has been authed)

This is the log out of jive-messengers debug-log:
2005.06.24 19:32:26 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/80.138.86.79,port=2789,localport=5222
2005.06.24 19:32:27 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/212.112.238.55,port=40073,localport=5269
2005.06.24 19:32:27 RS - Received dialback key from host: amessage.de to: kub.kicks-ass.net
2005.06.24 19:32:27 RS - Error, incoming connection already exists from: amessage.de
2005.06.24 19:32:56 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/212.112.238.55,port=40098,localport=5269
2005.06.24 19:32:56 RS - Received dialback key from host: amessage.de to: kub.kicks-ass.net
2005.06.24 19:32:56 RS - Error, incoming connection already exists from: amessage.de
2005.06.24 19:33:50 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/212.112.238.55,port=40126,localport=5269
2005.06.24 19:33:50 RS - Received dialback key from host: amessage.de to: kub.kicks-ass.net
2005.06.24 19:33:50 RS - Error, incoming connection already exists from: amessage.de
2005.06.24 19:33:57 Connect Sockethttp://addr=/212.112.238.55,port=40130,localport=5269
2005.06.24 19:33:57 RS - Received dialback key from host: amessage.de to: kub.kicks-ass.net
2005.06.24 19:33:57 RS - Error, incoming connection already exists from: amessage.de

Anyone can help?

btw: the newest nightly build i can get from download area is named:
jive_messenger_2005-06-13.zip
So i need a url were to find newer things.

best regards

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 24, 2005 1:10 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Could you find out which software the servers you are having problems with are using? From the logs I see that the remote server is trying to establish an incoming connection to kub.kicks-ass.net but since there is an existing connection then the new connection is being rejected. I don''t know why the remote server is creating a new connection if one already exists, unless the existing connection was closed and JM assumes that it''s still active.

Could you update to the latest nightly build and try again? If the problem persists can you verify (using netstat or some other tool) if the remote server has another connection to your server? A possibility could be that the remote server closed the previous socket connection but didn''t send a </stream> element and due to network configuration Java is not getting that the connection was closed. If that is the case and the remote server cannot be modified to send the </stream> element then you will have to decrease the idle timeout for closing connections.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 24, 2005 1:43 PM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

thx for superfast reply.
I will try this all and keep you up to date.

regards

Message was edited by:
Jonathan Yih

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 24, 2005 1:43 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Nightly build are located here: http://www.jivesoftware.org/nightly.jsp. Press F5 to force a refresh if you are seeing old builds. Latest is as of today.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 24, 2005 2:04 PM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

thx

I updated like i was told.
Same Problems.
I use another client now for jive and my mate is still using psi.
Maybe depends on that clients.
Looks like the problem is gone in this lineup.
I will test later on more exactly.
Will keep you informed.

best regards

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 25, 2005 7:08 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hello

The problem did not appear since we do not use Psi anymore.
The main server we test with, is the jabberd 1.4, amessage.de.
I''ll keep you informed.

regards

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 25, 2005 2:34 PM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hmm, s2s wouldn''t be different depending on the client you are using. I guess there should be another reason.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 26, 2005 8:42 AM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hello Gato

maybe you are right, but tests result is so far:
The problem persists not on any clients we use.
Most problems are when psi-user is on jive-messenger.

But the problem changed since the last update of JM a bit.
Here the actual problem in simple words:

user A is using jive-messenger, with Psi
user B using jabberd 1.4, with exodus, Gaim or something else

user A is unable to see user B online, but A is able to send B a message
User B is able to see user A online, but can''t send him a message

In all other configurations we tried JM is running absolutely perfekt!

best regards

Message was edited by:
Jonathan Yih

dombiak_gaston

3,730 posts since
Sep 26, 2001

Jun 26, 2005 9:00 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

So what your test case is telling is that serverB (amessage.de) is not being able to connect to serverA (JM). Could you post the debug log (and any error related to connectivity problem)? To make the test simpler let''s just focus on message sending. Once userB is able to send userA a message we can then focus on presences. BTW, sending messages should be independent from the client you are using.

Regards,

-- Gato

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 26, 2005 11:51 PM

in response to: dombiak_gaston

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hello

I will try to follow and find some mates for further tests
and will keep you informed.

best regards

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 30, 2005 9:50 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

Hello

At this time it looks like the problem does not apear anymore.

For this i would say my question is answered very well.
Thank you very much!!!

best regards.

Jonathan Yih

21 posts since
Jun 17, 2005

Jun 30, 2005 9:52 AM

in response to: Jonathan Yih

Re: s2s dont work for me.

The problem seems to be solved now.
So big thanx for your help!!!

best regards

Go to original post

Jun 17, 2005 12:21 PM

s2s dont work for me.

Actions

More Like This